The scholar’s question was a deliberate theological and legal trap that was set by the Pharisees. By the first century, Jewish rabbis had calculated that the Torah contained 613 individual commandments. If one of these was singled out over the others He would have been accused of diminishing the rest of the Law.
Instead of choosing one law over another, Jesus cites from Deuteronomy, “Love the Lord your God” and pairs it with Leviticus, “Love your neighbor as yourself.” Rather than picking one law to invalidate the rest, He reveals the animating principle that exists behind every law in Scripture, authentic love (charity).
It is easy for us to lack such an understanding when it pertains to what is being asked of us through religious practice- attending Mass on Sundays and Holy Days of Obligation, observing fasts, and keeping moral boundaries. Following laws out of duty or the fear of punishment is a starting point, but is not the ultimate destination.
If rules are kept strictly out of obligation we are treating faith as a routine checklist instead of something that transforms. Through such a disposition of mind resentment grows as we solely see God as a taskmaster or one who lies in wait to catch our mistakes. It is here that minimalism sets in where we strive to do the bare minimum of what is being asked.
We are being asked not simply for compliance, but for internal conversion that must take place. Church laws and moral precepts are not hoops put in the way for us to jump through. They are formative tools that are designed to assist us in moving outward and thus the ability to grow in our ability to love (neighbor, self, and God).
Through Jesus telling His disciples, “I no longer call you servants… I have called you friends” we see a shift in our relationship with God’s law. If done under obligation Law is an outside force that is telling us what to do. If done out of love Law becomes the desire to align ourselves with God’s will which is what sets us free and sends us forth in order to love neighbor, self, and God.
The Church’s ultimate goal for us is that we become so united with God that His love naturally flows through us. Rules give structure to our life, but it is love which gives them life. The invitation that the Gospel makes is to move past seeing rules as a burden that must be carried in order that we may begin to see them leading us directly into a transforming relationship with God.
Let us strive to enter more fully into the life of the Church in order that such transformation may take place within the depths of hearts; leading us towards the liberation that takes place when we enter fully and without reservation into the love that is the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit.